The Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic decides on constitutional complaints against the rulings of the ordinary courts and in October 2026 confirmed that the lunar dust samples from the 1970s remain the property of the Czech Academy of Sciences.

The Constitutional Court is the body that, in the Czech legal system, decides on constitutional complaints lodged against the rulings of the ordinary courts. It rejected a woman's complaint in the dispute over lunar dust samples as manifestly unfounded, thereby confirming that the samples belong to the Czech Academy of Sciences; the decision was published on 1 October 2026 [1][2][3][4].
The dispute over lunar dust
The proceedings concerned small fragments of rock, minerals and glass obtained by the Soviet probes Luna 16, Luna 20 and Luna 24 between 1970 and 1976 and kept in 15 glass ampoules and one plastic sample holder [1][2]. The material was received for scientific research from the Soviet side by the former Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, but decades later it turned up in the possession of the daughter of a scientist who had worked with it earlier [3]. The Academy of Sciences learned of this in 2020 in connection with an application for an export permit and brought an action for the return of the items [3]. The woman claimed that her mother had received the samples directly from Soviet colleagues and that the family had since held them as their own property, without the Academy ever missing them [1][3].
Rulings of the ordinary courts
The Prague 6 District Court and, after it, the Municipal Court in Prague ruled that the family must hand the samples over to the Academy [1][2]. The verdict was subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court as well [1][2]. According to Supreme Court spokeswoman Gabriela Tomíčková, the courts, on the basis of archival documents and witness testimony, concluded that the samples had always been handed over to the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences and not to individual persons, and they also stressed how exceptional it would be for such a rare material to be given to a private person [1][2][4].
Decision of the Constitutional Court
In her constitutional complaint the woman argued that the factual and legal conclusions of the ordinary courts were in extreme conflict with the evidence taken, and claimed that her mother had held the samples for decades in the belief that they were her own property [1][2][4]. A panel of the Constitutional Court with rapporteur Martin Smolek, however, stated that the woman overlooks the coherent chain of argument of the ordinary courts, which rested above all on contemporary documents titled "Act on the Handover of Lunar Dust Samples" from 1971, 1973 and 1977, in which the receiving persons, including the complainant's mother, were described as authorised representatives of the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences [3]. The court stated that this is probably a unique subject of court proceedings even on a worldwide scale, which, however, from a legal point of view does not require any special effort from the courts, and it rejected the complaint as manifestly unfounded [1][2][4]. A panel with rapporteur Tomáš Langášek stated that freedom of movement may be restricted in a defined area also for the sake of nature protection, and that the public interest in it outweighed the complainant's interest in this case. [7] The Constitutional Court also rejected as manifestly unfounded the complaint of a man from Prague who challenged the ban on leaving the marked trails in parts of the Šumava National Park, introduced to protect the western capercaillie. [7] The Constitutional Court had earlier rejected a similar petition from senators, then mostly on formal grounds. [6] Since 1 July 2023 the noise limits in some categories have been raised by five to 13 decibels; for example, the daytime hygiene limit along motorways and roads approved before 2001 rose from 60 to 68 decibels. [6] The court also pointed out that repeated relaxation of the limits increases the risk of a gradual weakening of protection and that with every further change the development of infrastructure will have to be carefully weighed against the right to a favourable environment. [5] On 7 October 2026 the Constitutional Court dismissed a petition by a group of senators to annul the government decree on the protection of health against noise and vibration, and held that the decree is in line with the constitutional order and with the law. [5] The rapporteur is Judge Jiří Přibáň, and the plenum of all 15 judges will vote on the judgment. [10] The law allows the government to set maximum fuel prices for no more than one year and, where the statutory grounds persist, to repeat the regulation. [14] The senators point out that a price regulation issued by government decree cannot be challenged directly before an administrative court. [12] The senators rely on earlier case law of the Constitutional Court, under which price regulation must not touch the essence of the freedom to do business and must allow costs to be covered and a profit to be made. [14] In their petition the senators argue that the law entrusts the government with excessively broad powers and does not protect smaller sellers from a long-term loss, and they asked for the matter to be heard as a priority. [10] The Ministry of Finance does not agree with the petition and stated that it is ready to defend the law before the Constitutional Court. [14] A group of senators, represented by Tomáš Goláň (ODS), filed with the Constitutional Court a petition to annul the law that enables the government to regulate fuel prices by decree; the court received the petition on 5 October 2026 and published it on 14 October 2026. [10] In October 2026 the government began regulating fuel prices again in response to their rise on world markets, having resorted to a similar regulation already in spring. [15] The second of the resolutions on the taxation of prostitution, with Judge Veronika Křesťanová as rapporteur, dealt with legitimate expectations and stated that the complainant had not submitted evidence from which such an expectation would arise. [21] The complainant invoked repeated statements by politicians that prostitution is not subject to tax and also pointed out that the authorities had so far not taxed similar income. [26] According to the resolution prepared by rapporteur Jiří Přibáň, tax applies to the actual economic yield regardless of whether the activity is morally acceptable, and taxation therefore does not mean the state's approval of it. [22] The complainant objected that by taxing prostitution the state would itself become a pimp, which the court rejected on the grounds that the state does not seek enrichment from another's work but a fair distribution of the tax burden. [25] In a judgment of 2025 the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic concluded that income from voluntary prostitution is subject to income tax and that taxation is obstructed neither by international conventions against human trafficking nor by the criminal liability of pimping. [26] According to the Constitutional Court's resolution, earnings from prostitution belong among income from independent professions, just like the income of artists, trainers, athletes or models. [23] According to the judgment, the law enforcement authorities and the regional court should have examined more thoroughly how the freezing of funds would affect the material security of the children. [9] The Constitutional Court sided with a woman who, instead of maintenance owed, was assigned a car seized in criminal proceedings and later sold for 573 thousand crowns, and returned the matter for a new decision to the Regional Court in České Budějovice. [9] For the town of Kladno this was the fourth defeat in a dispute lasting four years. [8] Petr Borecký, the Central Bohemian Region's councillor for transport, described the court's decision as confirmation that the region had acted within the limits of the law. [13] The Constitutional Court rejected as manifestly unfounded the constitutional complaint of the town of Kladno against a decision of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic, which had upheld the procedure of the Central Bohemian Region in requiring towns to contribute financially to regional transport; the court published the resolution on 15 October 2026. [8] The mayor of Kladno, Milan Volf (Volba pro Kladno), stated that, under an earlier decision of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic, the participation of municipalities in co-financing transport is voluntary and the region may not enforce it as an obligation. [11] In 2022 the Central Bohemian Region introduced standards of transport service; Kladno was the only town that did not join the system, whereupon the region curtailed some services of Prague Integrated Transport and removed Kladno's city transport from it. [13] On 18 October 2026 the President of the Senate, Miloš Vystrčil, stated that he expects senators to file with the Constitutional Court a petition to annul some parts of the civil service act, which the Chamber of Deputies of the Parliament of the Czech Republic approved by overriding the president's veto. [18] The President of the Constitutional Court, Josef Baxa, stated that he would welcome a decision in the competence dispute still in 2026, but cannot guarantee that this deadline will be met. [17] At the beginning of September 2026 the plenum of the Constitutional Court rejected the objection of bias against rapporteur Pavel Šámal that the government had raised in this dispute. [17] In June 2026 President Petr Pavel lodged a competence action after the government announced that it did not count on his participation in the NATO summit in Ankara in July, and on 24 June the Constitutional Court issued an interim measure ordering the government to ensure his participation. [17]
The Constitutional Court rejected two complaints by the accused in the so-called bitcoin case, one concerning the police's engagement of a court-appointed expert and the other the refusal of access to part of the case file. [16]
According to the Constitutional Court, the police's procedure in engaging the expert cannot be called arbitrary, and any defects in the expert opinion may be addressed by the regional court when hearing the case. [16]
According to Seznam Zprávy, which drew on the court database, the Constitutional Court rejected two complaints by a woman who was retroactively assessed income tax on voluntary prostitution for 2013 and 2014, in both cases over 900 thousand crowns. [19]
The court thereby confirmed the legal opinion of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic that income from voluntary prostitution is taxable like other forms of self-employment. [19]
Rapporteur Jiří Přibáň stated in the first resolution that taxation does not mean moral approval of the activity, and the court rejected the objection that the state would become a pimp through taxation, since in its view the state pursues a fair distribution of the tax burden and regulation of the market. [19]
The second resolution concerned legitimate expectations, which in the court's view the woman had not substantiated with any evidence, although she referred to statements by politicians that prostitution is not taxable. [19]
The Constitutional Court rejected two constitutional complaints by a woman who was assessed income tax on voluntary prostitution; one was directed against a decision of the Regional Court in Ostrava, the other against a judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic of August 2026. [20]
A panel of the Constitutional Court with rapporteur Jan Svatoň upheld the complaint of a foreign woman in asylum proceedings, because neither the ministry nor the courts had examined whether she is a particularly vulnerable person. [24]
Vystrčil wants to entrust the filing of the petition to Senator Tomáš Goláň; the Chamber of Deputies of the Parliament of the Czech Republic had earlier overridden the veto of President Petr Pavel on this law. [27]
Chronology
- — The Constitutional Court ruled that lunar dust samples from the 1970s remain the property of the Czech Academy of Sciences. → iDNES.cz Pražský deník
- — On 5 October a group of senators submitted to the Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic a petition to annul the law under which the government may set maximum prices of petrol and diesel by decree; the court made the petition public on 14 October. ČTK / České noviny Novinky.cz
- — The Constitutional Court rejected a group of senators' motion to annul the government decree on protection of health from adverse effects of noise and vibration, so noise limits in the Czech Republic remain unchanged. → ČTK / České noviny ČTK / České noviny
- — Opposition parties announced that they want to turn to the Constitutional Court over the law on civil servants; according to Pirates MP Kateřina Stojanová, the Pirates are preparing the submission, and TOP 09 and Starostové are to join. → ČTK / České noviny iDNES.cz
- — The Constitutional Court rejected a woman's complaints against income tax on earnings from voluntary prostitution assessed for 2013 and 2014, thereby upholding the view of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic that such income is taxable. → ČTK / České noviny iDNES.cz
- — Opposition deputies and senators announced that they would challenge before the Constitutional Court the abolition of the president's power to appoint and recall heads of permanent missions to international organisations, and would also seek an interim measure; according to ČT24 the petition was filed on Friday, 23 October 2026. → ČT24 FORUM 24
- — The Constitutional Court overturned a ruling by the Regional Court in Plzeň and gave three children a new chance to obtain compensation for their grandmother's death in a train accident, which their mother had spent without court approval. → ČTK / České noviny iDNES.cz
Sources
- iDNES.cz — 1 October 2026
- Pražský deník — 1 October 2026
- Novinky.cz — 1 October 2026
- Blesk.cz — 1 October 2026
- ČTK / České noviny — 7 October 2026
- Novinky.cz — 7 October 2026
- ČTK / České noviny — 8 October 2026
- Zdopravy.cz — 15 October 2026
- Brněnská Drbna — 14 October 2026
- ČTK / České noviny — 14 October 2026
- Seznam Zprávy — 15 October 2026
- Echo24 — 14 October 2026
- Kladenský deník — 15 October 2026
- Blesk.cz — 14 October 2026
- Novinky.cz — 14 October 2026
- ČTK / České noviny — 14 October 2026
- Echo24 — 17 October 2026
- ČTK / České noviny — 18 October 2026
- Seznam Zprávy — 20 October 2026
- Deník.cz — 20 October 2026
- Deník.cz — 20 October 2026
- Echo24 — 20 October 2026
- Novinky.cz — 20 October 2026
- Novinky.cz — 20 October 2026
- iDNES.cz — 20 October 2026
- Lidovky.cz — 20 October 2026
- iDNES.cz — 18 October 2026