Pictured: Constitutional Court (illustrative photo)
Pictured: Constitutional Court (illustrative photo)Photo: Kirk, 2009 · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons

On 1 October 2026 the Constitutional Court published a decision by which it rejected the constitutional complaint of a scientist's daughter in a dispute over samples of moon dust, thereby confirming that the material belongs to the Czech Academy of Sciences. The samples are small fragments of rocks, minerals and glass obtained by the Soviet probes Luna 16, Luna 20 and Luna 24 in 1970 to 1976, stored in fifteen glass ampoules and one plastic sample holder [1][3][4].

Origin of the dispute

The samples were received in the 1970s from the Soviet side for scientific research by the then Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences. After decades, however, they turned up in the possession of the daughter of a scientist who had previously worked with the material. The Academy of Sciences learned of this in 2020 in connection with an application for an export permit and subsequently filed a lawsuit for the surrender of wrongfully held property [3].

Arguments of the parties

In its lawsuit the Academy of Sciences stated that the samples had been its property from the beginning and that the researcher had only taken them over in order to examine them professionally. The scientist's daughter, on the contrary, stated that her mother had received the samples directly from colleagues from the Soviet Union and that the family had held them as their own property for decades, without the Academy missing them [1][2][3].

Decisions of the courts

The Academy of Sciences was first proved right by the Prague 6 District Court and then by the Municipal Court in Prague; both concluded that the family must hand the samples over to the Academy. The verdict was subsequently confirmed also by the Supreme Court [1][2][4].

Supreme Court spokeswoman Gabriela Tomíčková stated in June 2026 that, on the basis of archival documents, testimony and other evidence, the courts had concluded that the samples were received by the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences and not by individuals, and that this was exceptionally rare material intended for scientific research, the donation of which to a private person would be entirely exceptional [1][2][4].

Complaint to the Constitutional Court

In her complaint the woman objected to an extreme discrepancy between the conclusions of the ordinary courts and the evidence taken, and stated that her mother had held the samples for decades in the belief that they were her property; she also proposed a suspension of the enforceability of the court decisions [1][2][4]. The Constitutional Court, in a panel with judge rapporteur Martin Smolek, rejected the complaint as manifestly unfounded and pointed to the coherent chain of reasoning of the ordinary courts. As the key evidence it identified the documents "Act on the Handover of Moon Dust Samples" of 30 April 1971, 14 June 1973 and 10 June 1977, in which the persons taking over the samples, including the complainant's mother, were designated as authorized representatives of the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences [3]. The court stated that "although moon dust samples undoubtedly do not belong among things over which legal disputes are often conducted – even on a worldwide scale this is apparently an entirely unique subject of court proceedings – the case under consideration does not, from the point of view of law, reach excessive complexity requiring special effort on the part of the courts" [1][2][4].

Related articles: Constitutional Court, Czech Academy of Sciences

Chronology

  • — The Constitutional Court ruled that lunar dust samples from the 1970s remain the property of the Czech Academy of Sciences. iDNES.cz Pražský deník

Sources

  1. iDNES.cz — 1 October 2026
  2. Pražský deník — 1 October 2026
  3. Novinky.cz — 1 October 2026
  4. Blesk.cz — 1 October 2026