The Czech Academy of Sciences is a system of public research institutions that succeeded the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences; it fought a court battle over the ownership of lunar dust samples from the 1970s.

Headquarters of the Academy of Sciences on Národní in Prague, Czechia, 2017
Headquarters of the Academy of Sciences on Národní in Prague, Czechia, 2017Photo: Czech Academy of Sciences, 2017 · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The Czech Academy of Sciences (AV ČR) is a public institution that brings together scientific institutes engaged in basic research. It is the successor to the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, which received samples of lunar material from the Soviet side; decades later they became the subject of a court dispute with the daughter of the scientist who had worked on the samples. The dispute ultimately confirmed that the samples remain the property of the academy, and it reached the Constitutional Court.

The dispute over the lunar dust samples

The small fragments of rocks, minerals and glass that the Soviet probes Luna 16, Luna 20 and Luna 24 brought back from the Moon between 1970 and 1976 were received by the then Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences from the Soviet side for scientific research [3]. The material is stored in 15 glass ampoules and one plastic sample holder [1][4]. After decades, the samples turned up in the possession of the daughter of the scientist who had worked with them; according to the daughter, the family had held them as their own property [1][3]. The academy learned of this in 2020 in connection with an application for an export permit and filed a lawsuit for the surrender of an unlawfully held item [3].

Court rulings

The Prague 6 District Court and then the Municipal Court in Prague ruled that the family must hand the samples over to the academy [1][2][4]. The verdict was subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court [1][2][4]. The Supreme Court spokeswoman Gabriela Tomíčková said that, on the basis of archival documents and witness testimony, the courts concluded that the samples had always been handed to the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, not to specific individuals, and that this was an exceptionally rare material intended for scientific research, the donation of which to a private person would be entirely exceptional [1][2][4].

Ruling of the Constitutional Court

The scientist's daughter then turned to the Constitutional Court with a complaint in which she claimed that the factual and legal conclusions of the ordinary courts were in extreme conflict with the evidence taken, and she proposed a suspension of the enforceability of the court decisions [1][2][4]. The Constitutional Court, in a panel with Martin Smolek as rapporteur, rejected the complaint as manifestly unfounded [1][2][3][4]. It named as the key evidence the documents titled “Act of Handover of Lunar Dust Samples” of 30 April 1971, 14 June 1973 and 10 June 1977, in which all those who received the samples, including the complainant's mother, are listed as authorized representatives acting for the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences [3]. The court stated that although lunar dust samples are not among the things over which lawsuits are frequently fought, and are probably a unique subject of dispute even worldwide, the case is not legally particularly complex [1][2][4].

Timeline

  • — The Constitutional Court ruled that the lunar dust samples from the 1970s remain the property of the Czech Academy of Sciences. → iDNES.cz Pražský deník

Sources

  1. Ústavní soud rozetnul neobvyklý spor. Měsíční prach patří Akademii věd, rozhodl · iDNES.cz · 1 October 2026
  2. Vzorky měsíčního prachu získané v 70. letech zůstávají majetkem Akademie věd ČR · Pražský deník · 1 October 2026
  3. Měsíční prach nepatří dceři vědkyně, která ho zkoumala, potvrdil Ústavní soud · Novinky.cz · 1 October 2026
  4. Neobvyklý spor o měsíční prach řešil Ústavní soud: Rodina vědkyně jej musí předat Akademii věd · Blesk.cz · 1 October 2026