Pictured: Constitutional Court (illustrative image)
Pictured: Constitutional Court (illustrative image)Photo: Kirk, 2009 · CC BY 2.5 · Wikimedia Commons

On 12 November 2026 the Constitutional Court set aside a decision of the Regional Court in Plzeň, which had refused to award three children compensation for damage in criminal proceedings. The Regional Court in Plzeň must decide the matter again. The Constitutional Court stated that the children “fell through the sieve” of the statutory regime and that the result was exceptionally unjust for them; the courts should have limited formalism and bridged the gap in the law.[1][3]

Subject of the dispute

The children’s relative died in a train accident and České dráhy sent compensation to the children’s account. Their legal representative withdrew and spent the money without the court’s permission. The children’s claim was not filed in time in the insolvency proceedings of the representative, and the appointed guardian could no longer meet the deadline, because it had expired three months earlier.[1][2] In the criminal proceedings, the district court referred the children to civil proceedings. The regional court did not award compensation, reasoning that because of the insolvency the criminal court cannot decide on it.[1][2]

Conclusion of the Constitutional Court

The Constitutional Court stated that it is the judge’s duty to look for a truly just solution. Judge-rapporteur Lucie Dolanská Bányaiová stated in the judgment that the regional court’s interpretation is formally correct but does not meet this requirement.[1] In view of the exceptional circumstances, the regional court is to award compensation directly in the criminal proceedings. The claim cannot be asserted in the insolvency, but it will serve as an enforcement title, so after the insolvency ends the children will be able to enforce it through a bailiff without a new lawsuit.[1][2] The anonymised judgment is available on the website of the Constitutional Court.[1]

Chronology

  • — The Constitutional Court overturned a ruling by the Regional Court in Plzeň and gave three children a new chance to obtain compensation for their grandmother's death in a train accident, which their mother had spent without court approval. ČTK / České noviny iDNES.cz

Sources

  1. ČTK / České noviny — 12 November 2026
  2. iDNES.cz — 12 November 2026
  3. ČT24 — 12 November 2026